Skip to main content

Federal IDR: your options compared.

You don't need convincing that IDR recovers money. You've seen it. The question is how much of that recovery you keep, and whether the share you give up should keep growing as your volume does. Sydra is priced on per claim and subscription models rather than a percentage of recovery, so the cost of the service stops scaling against you at exactly the point your volume makes it most expensive.

Practice executive comparing two payment offers across printed documents

Cost

Contingency firm
Typically 20% of every recovery
In house with Sydra
Per claim or subscription, quoted to volume
Sydra files for you
Per claim or subscription, quoted to volume

Your time per claim

Contingency firm
Minimal
In house with Sydra
About five minutes
Sydra files for you
Minimal

Who owns the submission

Contingency firm
The firm
In house with Sydra
Your billing team
Sydra files for you
Sydra, with your approval

Scales with volume

Contingency firm
Cost scales with every dollar recovered
In house with Sydra
Cost stays flat as volume grows
Sydra files for you
Cost stays flat as volume grows

Handles related litigation

Contingency firm
Yes
In house with Sydra
No
Sydra files for you
No

When is a contingency firm the right answer?

A firm is genuinely the better choice in three situations. If the dispute has escalated beyond IDR into litigation, you need counsel and software will not help. If you are fighting a broader contract or network fight with a payer, IDR is one front in a larger matter and it should be run by lawyers. And if you have no billing staff at all and want zero involvement, a firm that takes a percentage carries all of the risk — that is what the percentage buys.

Where the percentage stops making sense is volume. A contingency rate that is reasonable on four claims a year is expensive on four hundred, because the cost grows with every dollar you recover while the work per claim does not.

If you are the firm, not the practice

Firms filing on behalf of client practices use Sydra too, and for a different reason. The constraint on an IDR practice is reviewer hours per case, which is why small disputes get declined. The argument there is recoveries per FTE, not cost per recovery, and it is set out on its own page.

See the per FTE argument

Common questions

When is a contingency firm the right answer?

A firm is genuinely the better choice in three situations. If the dispute has escalated beyond IDR into litigation, you need counsel and software will not help. If you are fighting a broader contract or network fight with a payer, IDR is one front in a larger matter and it should be run by lawyers. And if you have no billing staff at all and want zero involvement, a firm that takes a percentage carries all of the risk — that is what the percentage buys.

What is the difference between in house with Sydra and Sydra files for you?

In house with Sydra, your billing team spends about five minutes per claim and owns the submission. When Sydra files for you, Sydra owns the submission with your approval and your time per claim is minimal. Both are priced on per claim or subscription models rather than a percentage of recovery.

Does Sydra handle related litigation?

No. If the dispute has escalated beyond IDR into litigation, you need counsel and software will not help.

Get your number on a 15-minute call.

Bring your monthly out of network volume and what your current arrangement takes off the top. You will see the per claim comparison on your own figures. Nothing to sign.

Fifteen minutes on one of your own denied claims. If it qualifies you will see the dollar figure before the call ends, and there is nothing to sign.

Not ready to talk? Send one denied out of network EOB instead and you'll get a written IDR eligibility check and a dollar estimate back within one business day. Questions first? Email sales@sydrahealth.com.

Sourced references
  1. 1. CMS Federal IDR Q1/Q2 2025 Public Use FileReleased January 21, 2026cms.gov/nosurprises/policies-and-resources/reports
  2. 2. CMS Federal IDR Q4 2025 Public Use FileQuarter 4, 2025. Source for the per CPT area average initial payment and median figures in the Practice A table on the homepage. Geography and median denominator are pending confirmation from ops; see the TODO above PRACTICE_A in src/lib/content/homepage.ts.cms.gov/nosurprises/policies-and-resources/reports
  3. 3. Sydra client records, presented with client permissionProvenance for the Sydra performance figures in SYDRA_PERFORMANCE (src/lib/idr/proof-points.ts): 92% across 113 decided cases, 82.9% across 76 decided cases under the client's prior contingency firm, and the CPT 19318 award of $50,742.00 against a $2,500 QPA. Decided cases only; excludes withdrawn, ineligible, and pending disputes. Not federal data and not a category benchmark.
  4. 4. Georgetown University CHIR · Health Affairs webinarMarch 2026. 3.4 million disputes through June 2025; 88% win rate; median award ~4.5x in network rate
  5. 5. Zelis: NSA IDR Eligibility ChallengesMarch 2026. 44% of 2024 IDR cases challenged as ineligible by non initiating party
  6. 6. ACEP analysis of CMS data~10% of eligible claims estimated to reach IDR arbitration
  7. 7. Brookings Institution NSA Arbitration DatabookApril 2026brookings.edu/articles/no-surprises-act-arbitration-databook
  8. 8. ACR: Providers Prevail in Vast Majority of IDR ClaimsJanuary 2026. 88% of disputes found in provider's favor; 87% of awards exceeded QPA
  9. 9. No Surprises Act: Public Law 116-260, Division BB, Title I
  10. 10. Federal IDR regulations: 45 CFR Part 149ecfr.gov/current/title-45/subtitle-A/subchapter-F/part-149
  11. 11. CMS No Surprises Act overviewcms.gov/nosurprises
  12. 12. HHS HIPAA for professionalshhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals
  13. 13. CMS Final Rule: No Surprises Act IDR overhaul (HHS, DOL, Treasury, OPM)Administrative fee reduced from $115 to $15. Batching of multiple claims now permitted to lower costs and speed resolution. New IDR Gateway centralized platform rolling out in phases.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/federal-rule-takes-aim-saving-taxpayer-dollars-health-care-bureaucracy-reducing-dispute-fees
Clinician and a practice advisor reviewing claim figures on a tablet in a hospital lobby

Book a demo

We'd welcome a short call to see whether this is worth pursuing. Bring one denied out of network claim and you will see what federal IDR would do with it before the call ends.

Or email sales@sydrahealth.com with a question.